The Knee, ISSN: 1873-5800, Vol: 23, Issue: 2, Page: 203-8

Inter-observer and intra-observer reliability of mechanical axis alignment before and after total knee arthroplasty using long leg radiographs

Bowman, Anneka; Shunmugam, Meenalochani; Watts, Amy R; Bramwell, Donald C; Wilson, Christopher; Krishnan, Jeganath
Knee

Highlights

  • We examine the impact of surgeon level of experience and knee alignment measurements.
  • High inter-and intra-observer reliability of long leg radiograph alignment measures.
  • Bland–Altman plots demonstrating reliability of knee alignment measures.
  • Surgeon level of experience does not significantly affect reliability of measures.

 

Abstract

 

Background

Long leg radiographs (LLRs) are commonly performed for assessment of mechanical alignment and operative planning in patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The aim of this study was to determine the inter- and intra-observer reliability of alignment measured by observers of different levels of experience.

 

Methods

Forty patients on the waiting list for a TKA had pre- and post-operative standardised LLRs. We analysed the measurements of mechanical axis alignment between an orthopaedic surgeon, a senior orthopaedic registrar, a junior orthopaedic registrar, and a medical student. Reviewers performed blinded measurements on the same computer screen. These measurements were repeated three months later to assess intra-observer reliability. Furthermore high-resolution screens were compared with standard hospital computer screens to investigate whether monitoring quality influenced the accuracy of measurements of alignment.

Results

Inter-observer reliability was high for pre-operative LLRs with an intra-class correlation (ICC) of >0.9 at all experience levels. Post-operative ICC was lowest between the surgeon and the medical student at 0.7. Intra-observer reliability was high at all experience levels. Larger deformities appeared to have exaggerated measurements for both pre- and post-operative images. There appeared to be no effect of the monitor size and quality on the accuracy of measurement.

 

Conclusions

Long leg radiographs can be used to measure mechanical axis alignment with strong reliability across different levels of experience. This information is important for the evaluation of knee alignment measurements in current clinical practice, to assess severity of deformity and to accompany pre-operative planning and post-operative evaluation.

Level of evidence

III


Download article