Posterior Soft Tissue Repair After Primary THA is Durable at Mid-term Followup: A Prospective MRI StudyMcLawhorn, Alexander, S., MD, MBA1,a; Potter, Hollis, G., MD2; Cross, Michael, B., MD1; Boettner, Friedrich, MD1; Lim, Weiyang, MBBS, FRCR, MMED2; Lee, Yuo-yu, MS3; Pellicci, Paul, M., MD1
Background The enhanced posterior soft tissue repair has reduced the frequency of dislocation after primary THA performed through the posterolateral approach. However, the long-term integrity of the repair is unknown and could influence surgeon choice regarding surgical technique and THA approach.
Questions/Purposes We asked: (1) What is the durability of the enhanced posterior soft tissue repair at a minimum of 49 months using MRI to evaluate soft tissue to bone integrity? (2) How does the appearance of the posterior soft tissues change during this time? (3) Are there patient characteristics associated with the long-term imaging appearance of the posterior repair?
Methods All patients without a contraindication for MRI who were undergoing unilateral primary uncemented THA through a posterior approach between February and May 2005 were eligible for inclusion. Ninety percent consented to participate (36 of 40 patients), and 30 patients were followed prospectively with MRI postoperatively and again at 3 months; of those, 22 (73%; 12 men, 10 women) completed the study by having another MRI study at a minimum of 49 months (mean, 51 months; range, 49-59 months). Each patient underwent metal-artifact-reduction sequence MRI to evaluate the integrity of the posterior soft tissues, which had been repaired anatomically during primary THA at a minimum of 4 years earlier. The results were compared with those of prior MR images obtained immediately after surgery and at 3 months postoperatively. All patients were given a self-reported modified Harris hip score at the time of the most recent MRI study (maximum score = 81).
Results At latest followup, 21 of 22 (96%) patients had a posterior capsule in contact with bone, and 21 of 22 (96%) had an intact quadratus femoris. Twenty-one patients (96%) had soft tissue or a scar from the piriformis and conjoined tendons in continuity with bone. In these cases, the interface between the piriformis and conjoined tendons and the greater trochanter observed immediately postoperatively and at 3 months postoperatively became filled with hypointense tissue, with signal characteristics similar to tendon. Time from surgery was most associated with changes in native tendon-to-bone distances (p < 0.001) and MRI signal intensity of the repair (p < 0.001).
Conclusions At followup of just more than 4 years, the posterior capsule and quadratus femoris most often were healed to bone. In the majority of patients, scar tissue between the piriformis and conjoined tendons and bone matured to achieve orientation and signal intensity resembling native tendon. We believe the enhanced posterior soft tissue repair facilitates this process. Our results provide a plausible explanation for improved postoperative stability observed in patients receiving an enhanced soft tissue repair compared with those in whom a repair is not performed.
Level of Evidence Level IV, therapeutic study.